online ordering

Order from PICK UP Order from doordash Order from ubereats

Reserve your table

Enjoy a dining experience by reserving a table at our restaurant. Ensure your place for a wonderful meal today!

reservations

Impress Your Guests

Group Reservations And Parties

Parties / private events

previous slide next slide

Fast And Efficient
The Same Great Food
Order from Toast Order from doordash Order from ubereats
Enjoy a dining experience by reserving a table at our restaurant
If you do not see any available reservations online. please call the restaurant directly!
reservations
Unforgettable Celebrations
Private Dining Perfection
parties

WELCOME TO MILL CREEK TAVERN

Mill Creek, a favorite neighborhood restaurant in Bayville, offers a relaxed and casually elegant setting for enjoying seasonally inspired, flavorful American cuisine. Our dinner menu features daily specials available in both the dining room and bar. At the bar, you'll discover an exceptional wine list, local micro-brews, and a diverse selection of handcrafted specialty cocktails. We welcome private parties, large groups, and special events, with dedicated private dining and event spaces available. Mill Creek Tavern is renowned for its warm hospitality and great value. We can't wait to see you soon! Cheers, Rich!

American cuisine's finest

Private parties, large groups & special events are welcome, with private dining & event space available. Mill Creek Tavern is known for welcoming guests with excellent value and warm hospitality. We also have a full service off-premise catering division called Mill Creek Catering & Events. We look forward to seeing you soon.

Reviews

Review by - Google

five star review by Robert B:

This was the third time we had been here. First time for Happy Hour, which they have every day. Needless to say, we sat at the bar. The food was terrific as always, and drinks were very well made. I highly recommend this establishment.

Review by - Google

five star review by Nicky M:

Delicious food. Always great portions. Close, convenient and delicious. Tonight we had the Buffalo spring rolls and blackened quesadilla, angus cheeseburger sliders and rigatoni & blackened skirt steak. It was perfect.

Review by - Google

five star review by Scott D:

We have eaten here many times as we live in town. This weekend was my Grandson's Baptism. My Son and his Wife used the private room for a brunch, not only was the food spectacular but the service was excellent. I highly recommend coming here for a party.